The precautionary principle, i.e. theoretically structured panic in the times of COVID-19
Article Sidebar
October 6, 2020
September 30, 2020
Abstract
The article deals with the precautionary principle. A hypothesis was formulated that the actions of decision-makers during the COVID-19 epidemic prove that this principle is a useful and valuable instrument for supporting decisions. The experience of a pandemic, associated with the need to justify drastic preventive actions, neutralizes a large part of the arguments critical of the precautionary principle. At the same time, the same research material enables new conclusions to be drawn about the practical application of the precautionary principle. The first part of the article discusses the concept of the precautionary principle, its definition, and the most important voices critical of it. The second one demonstrates that the observed current practice of applying this principle neutralizes a significant part of the charges made against it. Moreover, starting from the same observations, new areas of reflection on the precautionary principle in the context of making economic decisions in the conditions of uncertainty have been identified.
References
Akins A., Lyver P., Alroe H.F., Moller H. (2019), The Universal Precautionary Principle: Nee Pillars and Pathways for Environmental, Sociocultural, and Economic Resilience, “Sustainability”, 11, 2357, http://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/11/8/2357 DOI:10.3390/su11082357.
Blavatskyy P. (2005), Back to the St. Petersburg Paradox?, “Management Science”, 51 (4), p. 677-678.
Gardiner S.M. (2006), A core Precautionary Principle, “The Journal of Political Philosophy”, 14(1), p. 33-60.
Gigerenzer G., Todd P.M. (2000), Simple Heuristics Tat Make Us Smart, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Gollier C., Treich N. (2003), Decision – Making Under Scientific Uncertainty: The Economics of the Precautionary Principle, “The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty”, 27 (1), p. 77-103.
Hansen S.F., Tickner J.A. (2013), The precautionary principle and false alarms- lessons learned, in: Late Lessons from early warnings: science, precaution, innovation, European Environmental Agency EEA, Report Nr 1, Vol. 201, pp. 17-45.
Hansson S.O. (1997), The limits of precaution, “Foundations of Science”, 2, p. 293-306.
Jablonowski M. (2005), High – Risk Decisions When Probabilities Are Unknown (or Irrelevant), „Risk Management”, 7(3), p. 57-61.
Jablonowski M. (2006), Precautionary Risk Management, Palgrave Macmillan, New York.
Jonas H. (1984), The Imperative of Responsibility, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press.
Klassen D. (2020), Updated COVID-19 (Coronavirus) statistics and analysis, https://nucleuswealth.com, dostęp: 02.05.2020.
Kogan L. (2005), Exporting Precaution: How Europe’s Risk Free Regulatory Agenda Threatens American Free Enterprise, Washington Legal Foundation, Washington DC.
Koźmiński A.K. (2004), Zarządzanie w warunkach niepewności, PWN, Warszawa.
Malinowski G.M. (2018), Zasada ostrożności, czyli heurystyka strachu oraz heurystyka odwagi w kontekście polityki gospodarczej, „Prakseologia”, 160/2018, s. 291-331.
Malinowski G.M. (2019), Uncertainty of Science and Decision Making – Problems with Evidence – Based Policy, „Edukacja Ekonomistów i Menedżerów. Problemy. Innowacje. Projekty”, 54 (4) s. 9-29.
Moss R.H., Schneider S.H., (2000), Uncertainties in the IPCC TAR, Recommendations To Lead Authors For More Consistent Assessment and Reporting, in: Guidance Papers on the Cross Cutting Issues of the Third Assessment Report of the IPCC, R. Pachauri, T. Taniguchi, K. Tanaka (eds.), World Meteorological Organization, Geneva, p. 33-51.
Potocki T., Opolski K. (2015), Decyzje w obliczu „niepewnych ryzyk” – rola heurystyk w nurcie racjonalności adaptacyjnej, „Finanse”, 1(8), s. 43-70.
Randall A. (2009), We already have risk management – Do we really need the precautionary principle?, “International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics”, 3, p. 39-74.
Raffensperger C., Tichner J. (1999), Protecting Public Health and the Environment: Implementing the Precautionary Principle, Washington, Island Press.
Randall A. (2011), Risk and Precaution, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Redziak Z. (2013), Niepewność w Podejmowaniu Decyzji, „Zeszyty Naukowe AON”, 2(91), s. 102-130.
Resnik D. B. (2004), The precautionary principle and medical decision making, “Journal of Medicine and Philosophy”, 29, p. 281-299.
Science Communication Unit for the European Commission DG Environment (2017), The Precautionary Priniple: decision making under uncertainty, http://ec.europa.eu/scienceenvironment-policy, z dn. 16.09.19.
Stirling A., Gee D. (2003), Science, precaution and practice, “Public Health Reports”, 117(6), p. 521-533.
Straffin P.D. (2004), Teoria Gier, „Scholar”, Warszawa.
Sunstein S.R. (2003), Beyond the precautionary principle, “University of Pennsylvania Law Review”, 151(3), p. 1003-1058.
Sunstein C.R. (2005), Laws of Fear: Beyond the Precautionary Principle, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Tickner J., Geiser K. (2004), The precautionary principle stimulus for solutions – and alternatives-based environmental policy, “Environmental Impact Assessment Review”, 24, 7-8, p. 801-824.
Wildavsky A. (1995), But Is It True? A Citizen’s Guide to Environmental Health and Safety Issues, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.
Wingspread (1998), Wingspread statement on the precautionary principle, “Rachel’s Environment and Health Weekly”, 586, http://www.rachel.org/en/node/3850.
Vlek Ch. (2009), A precautionary-principled approach towards uncertain risks: Review and decision – Theoretic elaboration, “Reasmus Law Review”, 2(2), p. 129-168.
Authors
The author of the article declares that the submitted article does not infringe the copyrights of third parties. The author agrees to subject the article to the review procedure and to make editorial changes. The author transfers, free of charge, to SGH Publishing House the author's economic rights to the work in the fields of exploitation listed in the Article 50 of the Act of 4 February 1994 on Copyright and Related Rights – provided that the work has been accepted for publication and published.
SGH Publishing House holds economic copyrights to all content of the journal. Placing the text of the article in a repository, on the author's home page or on any other page is allowed as long as it does not involve obtaining economic benefits, and the text will be provided with source information (including the title, year, number and internet address of the journal).
